Take the 2-minute tour ×
Server Fault is a question and answer site for professional system and network administrators. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am looking for a router that would fit the following requirements:

  • Two WAN interfaces: the primary is PPPoE, the secondary will link to a GigE port on another router (a 100Mbps link will suffice);
  • Two (ideally four) GigE LAN ports;
  • No requirement for a firewall;
  • No requirement for Wi-Fi;
  • Inexpensive.

The plan for the two WAN interfaces is as follows. All outbound traffic will go to the primary, with exceptions based on destination IP/subnet or possibly on src+dest IPs/subnets. Such exceptions should be routed to the secondary. It would be very nice if, should the primary go down, the secondary would automatically take over for all outbound traffic.

I am reasonably sure that I can put something together based on dd-wrt. However, I'd like to hear from you what alternatives are out there (especially something easier to set up for my use case, even if it means paying more for the hardware.)

share|improve this question

7 Answers 7

up vote 4 down vote accepted

Mikrotik 450G. 5 gigabit ports. 12 watt max power. about 100 USD.

Can a lot more (Firewall etc.) running a very specialized version of linux which you dont ahve acess too (i.e. there is a shell, but it is custom made and hides the file system from you).

VERY flexible. Whole range of routers. VERY powerfull (the 450G can run BGP4).

If that is too expensive, the 750G is cheaper, less memory, about 60 USD. Same features.

share|improve this answer
    
(+1) I haven't come across Mikrotik devices, but they look very interesting indeed. Thanks for the pointer. –  NPE Feb 1 '11 at 17:10
    
The really funny thing is that they scale. You can run them on x86 hardware (routeros) and even the one you buy from them can handle 1gbit links as small data room internet backbone for a LOW price. Unless yuo scale quite high they are pretty much "handling your whole public needs". –  TomTom Feb 1 '11 at 17:18

Have a look at Draytek (http://www.draytek.com), they do SoHo routers that fit your description, they also have both console and web configuration and are extremely resiliant.

If they don't offer what you want I would go straight to Cisco, but that'll increase the price of course

share|improve this answer

Have you considered any of the linux firewall projects?

My personal preference is PFsense, but you could also look at m0n0wall, ipcop, ipfire.

share|improve this answer

A Juniper SRX210 can have an ADSL PIM card in it and also accept ethernet connections... they're not cheap though :)

share|improve this answer

Juniper NetScreen firewalls running ScreenOS since about 5.4 or higher can do source policy-based-routing which sounds like what you want. The SSG5s are the entry units and go for less than $1000.

share|improve this answer

I've had a lot of success with OpenWRT on TL-WR1043ND boxes lately. They're cheap (< $50), low power(<10 Watts), gigabit ethernet etc. and then you can do whatever you like with it once it's installed, including splitting the switch into VLANs to suit your needs.

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks. As I mentioned in the question, dd-wrt -- which is closely related to OpenWRT -- is my default solution. –  NPE Feb 1 '11 at 17:14
    
Poke around with the 'switch_vlan' option in /etc/config/network then and pull one of the LAN ports into a 3rd VLAN on any cheap compatible hardware. –  Flexo Feb 1 '11 at 17:32

With inexpensive being a requirement, I would check out pfSense. It's a free open source router that is very robust and scalable with the company. I use it exclusively when cost is an issue, it's just so versatile and stable (last reboot was a 6mo. ago for maintenance).

One of the features is WAN load balancing with failover, you can pull bandwidth from both your PPoE, and your 2nd WAN line, and if one drops it still runs on the other. My book mentions policy routing which is like a firewall rule, but with a gateway field, it looks like you can get even finer control than just IP/Subnet. It does not mention limiting it to just one WAN but I would imagine it's very possible. If you do end up trying it, I would ask this on the pfSense forum (great resource if you run pfSense).

Is your 2nd WAN also PPoE? pfSense 1.2 does not support multiple PPoE connections, but version 2.0 does.

Also The built in firewall can be disabled if you already have a firewall solution.

I would try it out on a spare machine or the VMware appliance to see how it works for your setup.

share|improve this answer
    
The second WAN is a DOCSIS line with its own modem+router. To the router in question it's simply an IP/Ethernet uplink. –  NPE Feb 1 '11 at 17:17
    
Mikrotik. The 450G is cheaper, the 750G a LOT cheaper - with softrware - than theh ardware you otherwise buy ;) –  TomTom Feb 1 '11 at 17:17

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.