Updated to be more specific with what I'm dealing with. I thought I was on the right path before, but now things just feel more obscure.
I have no experience with Apache/Tomcat/Whatever TeamCity is running under, pretty much only worked in IIS before, and I am having a hard time understanding how to install a SSL certificate to use TeamCity with https.
I imported my cert into a keystore and I configured my server.xml file to point at my keystore following the directions. However, when I go to my site it says there is a problem with my certificate. It seems like the instructions from the CA, the instructions from TeamCity, and the instructions from Apache (which team city links to) are all different.
Can anyone help explain the steps I'm missing/skipping?
Note, this is running on a Windows box if that makes a difference.