up vote 8 down vote favorite
1
share [g+] share [fb]

I've been considering switching domain name registrars for some time now. However, I'm really worried about ending up with some deadbeat service that ends up losing my domains. I would stick with my current registrar (yahoo) but they haven't updated their admin panel since I got the domains 10 years ago. I needed to add a TXT record a couple of months ago and their support told me they don't allow that. :( I really wish I could stick with them since this is the first issue I've had with them but such is life.

I was considering going with register.com but I'm curious if anyone has any horror stories about them.

Given the subjective nature of this question let me clarify by saying I'm not interested in "the best" DNS registrar. Just tell me about any first hand experience you have.

link|improve this question
5  
GoDaddy uses hot chicks in their ads. – Will Jul 13 '09 at 16:18
feedback

12 Answers

up vote 4 down vote accepted

Seconded for Dreamhost, but I don't monitor my downtime for the domains I use with them - so I can't really comment on business critical availability. However, they have a great control panel and make leaving painfully easy if you want to, but I never have wanted to.

EDIT: If you do sign up, I joined when they had this 500,000th customer deal going on where I get 5 free domains per year, each year, as long as I'm a customer. A couple of my friends wanted that too, so I made them a promo code. Dreamhost gives you 97$ for a referral, but you can take that money and use it to add features to your referee's accounts. If you want 5 on-going free domains you can use my promo code when you sign up, it's "5FREESITES". I do get a discount on my bill from them if you use it, I think a month or two free.

Not trying to self promote here though, I just genuinely think he would appreciate the feature. If anybody has a problem with this message I don't mind if the code is removed.

link|improve this answer
Can you check to see if they allow you to add TXT records? – Spencer Ruport Jul 13 '09 at 21:52
For me, the only downtime was when they were upgrading their servers awhile back. Agreed with Garrett, leaving is very simple but never wanted to do so either. – Will Jul 13 '09 at 23:14
Yes, they allow: A, CNAME, TXT, NS, SRV, and AAAA – Garrett Jul 16 '09 at 15:35
Here is a demo of their control panel webapp: dreamhost.com/hosting-panel.html I've never had to contact them for support on a feature, I do everything through my panel and it's verrry simple. Love it. – Garrett Jul 16 '09 at 15:46
DNS management is under Domains > Manage Domains > click DNS under one of the domains. Apparently the demo doesn't have any fake domains to play with, but here's a screenshot some guy took of the DNS page: matthom.com/images/540.jpg – Garrett Jul 16 '09 at 15:51
feedback

I have used NameCheap for the last few months. They have self-service on their domain tools, and I have found everything I need on their domain admin control panel without having to rack my brain or contact their customer support, and lots of tools available for you. Payments by CC of course, and also by Paypal.

The site is a major visual mess, but I am happy so far, and would recommend them.

I found NameCheap as a recommendation on SO/SF.

link|improve this answer
feedback

I've been hosting my domain names at dreamhost.com and they've been great. I think it's been 5-6 years now I've been with them.

link|improve this answer
Thanks! See the comment I made to Garrett's answer. – Spencer Ruport Jul 13 '09 at 21:55
In Dreamhost's wiki, it says the following: More complicated setups: If you need special NS or TXT records, or have other more complicated requests, contact support. It's likely that we can accomodate your request. wiki.dreamhost.com/KB_/_Domains_/… – Will Jul 13 '09 at 23:11
cool thanks. I'll take a look at them. – Spencer Ruport Jul 14 '09 at 0:03
feedback

You don't have to use your registrar for DNS hosting. You don't have to change registrars to have somebody else provide DNS service for your domains, either. Check out easyDNS, for example.

I presently have my personal domains registered with GoDaddy. I find their ads in very poor taste, and they're always trying to upsell you to stuff you probably don't need or want, but they haven't annoyed me enough to go through the hassle of switching registrars. Yet. I do use their DNS hosting service, and it does allow TXT records. I haven't personally noticed any problems with their hosting service, but I've got a friend that has complained about vanishing MX records in the past. He swears by easyDNS for anything that needs to be truly reliable. I do use easyDNS for one domain that I manage for somebody else that uses a foreign registrar (ccTLD). The additional expense kind of sucks, but I don't trust the registrar for that domain. I've set up TXT records with easyDNS, so I know that works. They've got explicit SPF support in their interface, which is what I use TXT records for.

You could do worse than GoDaddy, so you should probably check them out if you can stomach navigating their website.

easyDNS is also a registrar, though they're not cheap (as compared to GoDaddy, at least).

Everybody I know is using either GoDaddy or easyDNS at the moment.

Update

The GoDaddy SOPA fiasco finally motivated me to go through the hassle of migrating. I've transferred domains I've registered to Namecheap. I haven't tried their DNS service, I'm using Rackspace Cloud DNS.

I also eventually experienced the "MIA MX record" problem myself. They were there in the management interface, but not showing up via dig. I didn't try contacting GoDaddy support, I manged to clear the problem up by vaporizing all the records and reloading them.

link|improve this answer
True, but I'd rather keep them one and the same to avoid confusion. – Spencer Ruport Jul 13 '09 at 16:25
feedback

I used EasyDNS for a domain some many years ago. They were very helpful and are very serious about what they do.

There's also always DynDNS, which is supported by just about every dynamic updater (if that's your bag).

I should also note that EasyDNS is as well.

Those are my two picks.

link|improve this answer
1  
I second DynDNS - we use several of their services. – Knox Jul 13 '09 at 21:24
EasyDNS is top notch, I just wish they were a bit cheaper. – Mark Johnson Jan 7 at 3:14
feedback

If you end up with GoDaddy, always do a search for a promo code. NEVER pay full price. There are always codes online to get what you need for cheap.

link|improve this answer
...to get what you need for cheap for the first payment. By default, your service will renew at the regular rate, which may have gone up since you first paid. It will almost certainly be difficult to turn off auto-renewal. – nobody Jan 3 at 6:42
feedback

I've been using http://www.1and1.com for many years now and they've been great. Cheap domain registration, decent control panel, additional services (if needed), and I can actually get a hold of a HUMAN for tech support if need be.

link|improve this answer
2  
I can't recommend against this strongly enough. I've been hosting servers with them for years, and every time I've moved a domain between servers (admittedly, 3 times in that period), disaster ensues. They cache IPs for second-level domains (example.com. A 127.0.0.1) indefinitely. To get them to fix their cache, you have to call in, get the one guy in the office who knows what that means, who will escalate to "the hostmaster". That person will take 1d6 weeks to fix the problem, never letting you know when it's done. I'm in the process of moving my domains away from them. – Bill Weiss Aug 31 '09 at 22:33
... the servers might stay, they've done a good job with those. Domains? No. – Bill Weiss Aug 31 '09 at 22:34
feedback

I've read some horror stories about GoDaddy at NoDaddy.com, but my limited experience with them has been alright.

One time I registered a domain through them for the full price, found a deal with BlueHost where you get the domain free with the purchase of hosting... and GoDaddy refunded my money and I was able to register the domain through BlueHost.

link|improve this answer
NoDaddy.com is MIA. Did I read something about GoDaddy buying it out? – Mark Johnson Jan 3 at 4:05
Wayback Machine FTW. – Mark Johnson Jan 3 at 4:07
feedback

I have used register.com, and they are ridiculously expensive compared to anyone else. $35 for a year! That is way too much. Considering you can get the same thing for less than $9 in many other places.

Also, they try to tie you in as much as possible. Releasing a domain from them involves so much red tape and a very arduous process. Faxes. Phone calls. Waiting period. No doubt designed to make you give up and stay with them. My experience in doing that convinced me never to use them again.

Right now I am using a co-branded version of godaddy.com. Now, I'm sure you'll dig up as many horror stories about how bad they are, etc. But all I can tell you is I have never experienced any problems. I am with them because they are very cheap, a long-standing company, and offer full domain control.

link|improve this answer
feedback

I've been enjoying dynadot.com for a while. It's simple, but allows me to do anything I would ever need to do.

Does anyone else have any experience with dynadot?

link|improve this answer
feedback

Godaddy is generally ok.

I have also had good experiences with dyndns.com.

link|improve this answer
feedback

for a name register Network solutions would be the most reliable IMO. Dreamhost is good cheap host.

link|improve this answer
How can Network Solutions justify a $35 registration cost? – James McMahon Oct 8 '09 at 3:26
feedback

Your Answer

 
or
required, but never shown

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.