Take the 2-minute tour ×
Server Fault is a question and answer site for professional system and network administrators. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've been working with HP's Server Automation tool suite for a long time, and while it's a great tool - it's too much for a small business or home network to use (more accurately: it's way too expensive for anything less than a large company to afford).

I'm somewhat familiar with Puppet and OpenNMS for provisioning and monitoring. After googling for other information, though, it seems there's not much in the way of management tools that are mature enough to use without a lot of effort to maintain them.

Are there any other FLOSS tools (commercially supported is fine) for managing:

  • server provisioning
  • patch control
  • software package pushing
  • etc

Expansion

  • integration with native provisioning is fine (kickstart, jumpstart, autoyast, unattend.txt, winpe, etc)
  • a GUI of some kind would be nice, but not required
  • I want to be able to setup, for example, an OS profile, and ship it to X-many devices, preferably with fields that would be filled-in during the process for hostname, IP, etc
  • agent-based is preferable to non-agent-based (ie, I know I could use soemthing like pssh for package and patch management, but that requires pre-shared keys as opposed to agent/certificate authentication)
  • being able to tie-in to Nagios, OpenNMS, or similar would be fantastic - so known ports, processes, and SNMP data would be great
  • virtualization support would be really helpful - but I'm OK with it not being able to create the VM, just populate/provision it

If the answer to this question turns out to be, "here's a bunch of tools that are part of the solution", I'm willing to build a wrapper of some kind for my own use.

share

locked by Mark Henderson Jan 21 at 21:13

This question exists because it has historical significance, but it is not considered a good, on-topic question for this site, so please do not use it as evidence that you can ask similar questions here. This question and its answers are frozen and cannot be changed. More info: help center.

7 Answers 7

up vote 9 down vote accepted

Puppet doesn't do the base system provisioning as far as I know. So you always also need the distibution's base automated system installation tool.

One could mention tools like

And some interesting ones have been named already.

These being mentioned, I believe, there are many things to take into account to answer that question:

  • What distributions(or general Operating Systems) are you running - what you want to deploy and manage, and what do you want/need your management server run on?
  • only for real hardware, or for virtualization, too?
  • Which type of virtualization?
  • do you need/want a GUI?
  • Who should use the system - what level of expertise do they have
  • what type and size of infrastructure should the tool(s) manage?
  • what type of organization is it for?
  • What exact type of functionality do you want and need? (I suspect, there will be quite a lot in the little "etc" you wrote above)

I mean, you want to make your whole infrastructure being depending and managed with that tool, you should really sit down a bit and think what you need and write it up (not tons of paper, but a few of the most important aspects!).

share

On RHEL there's Red Hat Satellite.

On Debian there's (google produced) debmarshal.

share

As I can't comment yet, I'm just answering here to add that the open source project based on RedHat Satellite is named spacewalk

share

I would recommend Puppet for any system information. Though as has been said, this doesn't handle provisioning of servers.

For patch management there are the following:

  • Red Hat => Satellite server.
  • CentOS / Fedora, => Spacewalk.
  • SuSE => SMT

I've also been playing around with a project called 'The Foreman' which integrates puppet with kickstart. This though is still in early development.

share

I learned about xCAT - which also seems to help fulfill at least part of the goals of my question.

Also, there is OCS for inventorying.

share

Right now The Foreman seems to be the best choice when it comes to Puppet integration.

But PuppetLabs are also working on a provisioning tool called Razor. There was a Presentation about it at PuppetCamp Munich which might be worth a look.

share

Ansible is a non agent-based management tool for ssh-based systems (focus seems to be Linux/Unix).

share

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.