Take the 2-minute tour ×
Server Fault is a question and answer site for professional system and network administrators. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'd like to know if someone was able to build a compact server for SOHO users (ie. to handle email, light CRM, file server) for a total price of €150/$200, and have enough room to host a regular size PCI card so it can also act as a PBX?

I took a look at Atom-based mini-ITX motherboards, picoPSU, and the ad hoc case, and I end up with a total cost of at least twice this :-/

Thank you.

share|improve this question

5 Answers 5

$200 is not safe. If you want simple bottom end get the cheapest Dell you can find and add second drive to it to give you RAID1.

This will be the safest way if you want a server. If you go with less then this, your data is not that important to you so just go buy an old something used thing.

That may be blunt, but how important is your data to you?

share|improve this answer
    
Great straight forward question! I would add what type of service are you expecting out of your PBX because a $200 server isn't going to perform well with all those services running... –  JJ01 Aug 3 '09 at 4:12

A $200 system isn't really feasible unless you get an old used system or parts being thrown out by a college or other institution; you can cobble parts together to fit that bill.

BUT

I wouldn't trust it. I use old systems for testing, for one-off things that aren't important tasks, etc...you'd be talking about slow systems with parts that are either uber-cheap or old and thus could fail without a good backup in place, so I hope the data isn't too important.

If you're talking about a server that is actually used for business, i.e., you have money riding on the data or will experience difficulty if it crashes or loses information, you seriously need to reconsider the amount of money you're budgeting for it or consider outsourcing...and it sounds like you need something reliable if you're going to use it as a PBX.

It's true that some old systems will run and run and run, but if I had money riding on keeping that system going, I would have money allocated for the system, a backup system of some sort for proper data recovery, and a backup computer for replacing the loaded system should it (when it will) fail.

You also might want to look at finding a way to separate your services a bit if for nothing else than to simplify management. You're saying you want email, web serving, PBX, and a file server, along with antivirus and backup on it? I've had cases where program interactions can cause issues (especially antivirus)...something to consider while planning. Also upgrading and if you decide to change your platform of choice for certain functions (like CRM products) can cause issues. Is it going to be an issue if your email platform needs to be changed or upgraded and it interferes with your web server, or if in the course of fixing email you take down all the other services?

One solution for that, especially if it really is lightly loaded, is VMWare or some other virtual solution. I'm not too happy with VMWare now that they're bullying other vendors to cut functionality from their products out of fear of their own business model being threatened (thus creating bigger opportunity for Citrix, Xen, KVM and Microsoft's Hyper-V) but I mention them because we're currently running 7 servers of light activity on a single Poweredge 2950 from Dell without issue so far. Here's an article from a guy who made a rather beefy server for $600 to run ESXi (which is free) and then you can create many small servers for each purpose and thus test, upgrade, and swap out platforms as needed (and if you get a better server later, install your VM platform of choice and just copy the virtual machines over with minimal hassle to your software installation and still get better performance!). The only thing that may be an issue is the PCI card for your PBX.

Please...reconsider the budget. Being budget conscious is one thing, but it will cost you more in aggravation and headache (and repair costs!) down the road if you go too far with saving money; if this is an important part of the business the budget should reflect that. Please please please, as someone who has seen others make the same mistake and pay for it later on...

share|improve this answer

You can always get a second hand server from ebay - won't be the newest, but it will fit the description and will probably be better able to cope with whatever you throw its way than a new cheap system

share|improve this answer

For that sort of system your price is unrealistic. Miniturised components cost more. You might be able to get a netbook but obviously that would not take a PCI card.

Secondly an Atom based board would not cope well with all that even with light use, they are optimised for the sort of things a single user does to make up for their lack of raw power.

If you are set on that price then perhaps you could get a 2nd hand slimline desktop. This would also allow you to use a pci card.

share|improve this answer

(I logged on with an OpenID account, but I don't see any Comment link)

Thanks for the tip, I hadn't thought about 2nd-hand slimline desktops. The problem is that I need new hosts to sell to customers.

I guess it's just not possible to build a compact host for that kind of money.

share|improve this answer
    
I don't think you get a comment link without a certain amount of reputation earned first. –  Bart Silverstrim Aug 2 '09 at 16:28
    
Side notes...older slimline Dells are something to be wary of for reliability, especially if you are conscious of your customer's perception of your business. We have labs and buildings with slimline Dells...GX50's, GX60s, etc...and we've had a number of the power supplies fail without warning, and had to replace them by scarfing from other spare slimlines of the same model because of the power supply design. You're also going to run into issues because if you're trying to create a turnkey system, you're using a lot of functions on each machine. You'd be better off with virtual appliances. –  Bart Silverstrim Aug 2 '09 at 16:41
    
Thanks a lot for the feedback guys. –  OverTheRainbow Aug 4 '09 at 9:34

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.