Take the 2-minute tour ×
Server Fault is a question and answer site for system and network administrators. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have a web application written in PHP where I would like to allow existing users to log into Windows computers, too. Re-hash of their passwords is doable (by requesting them to change the password). And to solve desync of passwords, I intend to have webapp authenticate users primarily against the domain.

I don't want to give webapp users accounts on the existing domain, which we can call example.local. Instead, I want to provide them accounts on a new domain, let's call it webapp.example.local.

From some research I have done, setting up a Samba4 domain and joining computers into this webapp.example.local domain would be one way to allow webapp users to log in. But, the computers should be members of the example.local domain.

How can I get computers that are members of and are authenticating against Windows 2008-based example.local to also authenticate users against webapp.example.local?

Magic keywords seem to be "trust relationship", "forest", etc, but at this point I haven't found a concrete example on how to establish this trust.

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

I'm not an expert on Samba4, so I cannot evaluate the limits of your design at that point. But from the AD point of view, what you want can be achieved using two separate domains and stablishing the trust relationship between both domains, so you are right on this point.

IMHO if you want two different domains, one for production (example.local) and another for resource management (webapp.example.local), bearing in mind that those two domains are hosted by different techologies (Native Microsoft AD and SAMBA4) should be better to set them in a non-contiguous DNS namespace, like example.local for production and resources.local for resource management. It's just a personal preference for AD management and not a real technical limitation.

Nevertheless I hope you could find usefull these two next links:

TechNet: Understanding Trust Types TechNet: Creating External Trusts

Hope it helps!

share|improve this answer
It's my intention to allow existing users of the webapp access to Windows machines. No "resource management" involved :-) Sadly, Samba4 seems to have issues with trust relationships in ... some ... direction, and the language explaining what domain needs to be configured to unidirectionally trust which domain is somewhat confusing. I'll play a bit and see if I can figure this out. –  Ivan Vučica Oct 25 '13 at 21:47
"Resource management" always depends on the point of view ;). Regarding the topic of "correct direction" of the trust… think in terms of "countries". If you want to visit Spain, when you arrive to the border, the border guard ask you for your passport. He then confirm that your passport is correct an let you continue to Spain. He do that because Spain trust in your country which in turns confirms that you are Ivan. So in this example the trust relationship is from Spain to your country. If you think now in terms of computers, your computers are in the example.local "country" and your users... –  SantiFdezMunoz Oct 26 '13 at 9:10
… that are from the "country" webapp.example.local wants to visit those computers that "lives" in example.local. If you follow the country example, example.local must trust in webapp.example.local in order to the authentication can be possible. Hope this trivial example could help you to understand better trust relationships directions (I think that this is a topic that Microsoft should explain "a little" better). –  SantiFdezMunoz Oct 26 '13 at 9:14

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.