1

Is it possible to connect all 24 disks to one raid card ? How do I connect these physically ? Do I need an expander ? Or is it-mode flushing sufficient ? I read it-mode flushing permits up to 1024 drives and software raid. (mdadm bcache megacli etc usage is not a problem ?

The Hardware I got :

2 Answers 2

3

Is it possible to connect all 24 disks to one raid card ?

That and WAY More - 250 are not unheard of SAS is a storage network protocol.

How do I connect these physically ?

Using a SAS cabinet that has the logic boards and physical slots for the discs.

Do I need an expander ?

Generally no. I mean, you need one, but the cabinet has one or more of them.

The Hardware I got :

Ah, the backplane. You are aware that there is DOCUMENTATION you should READ? You link to it, but you seem to think we should read it for you.

If you got that backplane - as a backplane, i.e. as single part - you bascially did not get a car but bought part of a car engine. This backplane is a part sold separately for upgrades and replacement IN STORAGE CHASSIS. As you can clearly read (if you read it) on 2-5 of the manual it has a TON of SAS HDD connectors on the back side. These generally are on the back side of a chassis with hot swap trays, where the discs then connect into those SAS connectors. And yes, those are then for SAS discs. The backplane also supports chaining, do you can have one SAS connection go from one backplane to the next. That is, btw., also described IN THE MANUAL YOU LINK - Chapter 3 (Dual Port and Cascading Configurations).

2
  • I guess I could not state my problem as a question clearly. I have the case (cabinet) of course. All I need to know is "Can I connect this 24 disk via this backplane using one cable SFF-8643 to SFF-8087 to a raid card LSI 9260-8i and setup software raid ?". As I understood one port gives access to all drives and other (J50) is for failover, other two (J49's) for external connections. I can read and understand these SAS and wikipedia in matter of minutes. But I dont have the actual hardware (Cable and card are misisng) and did not try it myself before. The question asks for experience. Aug 13, 2020 at 10:05
  • Not necessarily failover. SAS discs normally support both ports and the load is split. This is ALSO about scalability. Note, though, you can also plug SATA discs into an SAS expander - they are physically compatible. Yes, you can - no, we do not put up shopping lists for you.
    – TomTom
    Aug 13, 2020 at 10:19
1

It turns out board has built in sas expander , I was able to connect 24 disks into one lsi 2108 and without it mode flushing choosing raid1 (it creates raid 10 automatically) they work as expected. Benchmarks show 1.5 GB per second read and write. A little low than I expected since each disk is rated 250mb/sec read speed. Used linux disks utility , hdparm and dd for benchmark. Cache was enabled didnt see much difference adding sofwtware striped sdd caches (bcache) with 1MB cutoff in small files copy, other than slightly increased IO. Tested this copying random sized files created with dd if=/dev/urandom smaller than 1MB, timed with time command of bash. This was my first setup, I have seen cards and cables first time in my life. Answer is although documentation does not state clearly up to how many disks a cable or an adapter or a built in backplane expander supports and although many people insist that it-mode firmware flushing is required , they work out of the box.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .