I've set-up a basic Apache (2.2.x) and Tomcat (6.0.x) set-up using mod_jk for load balancing using the worker.properties file. Preliminary testing seems to show that this works relatively well, and it was quite easy to set-up.

However; the fact that it was so easy to set-up has got me a little worried. We're dealing with 100 - 300 concurrent users using the same web application (deployed on 2 or 3 Tomcat instances). I have done a little Googling and looking around on here and there seems to be more than 1 way to accomplish this (one example on here used a balancer:// style URL, which I've never seen before in an Apache config). For example, one question I ask myself is how reliable the load detection on mod_jk really is (Busyness, Session, Request, etc).

In your experience, does this set-up prove to be reliable in real world scenarios? Any pointers on improvements, pit falls or interesting literature/articles?

I've worked with Apache before, but am in no way an expert.

Thanks in advance.

  • I've figured out an additional way of doing this would be the Apache 2.2.x native AJP proxy and load balancer. Additional question: is this better/worse than the mod_jk approach? – pHk Apr 26 '10 at 12:18

"balancer://" is used by apache mod_proxy_balancer and probably with mod_proxy_ajp who is another way to connect apache to tomcat ajp than mod_jk.

I can't tell you a lot on the load detection reliability but I learned this from my experience :

  • Read carrefully the mod_jk directives manual
  • Check the timeout parameters, this is very important. Default infinite "reply_timeout" is very bad: if a tomcat is dead apache will keep threads busy and you can be flooded.
  • Read the mod_jk logs to look for errors
  • Let apache handle directly static content with JkUnMount directive to give tomcat only needed requests.
  • Use apache mod_cache if possible
  • Use the mod_jk watch page to check what is happening on your connectors.

An article on mod_jk/proxy-ajp: http://thoughts.contegix.com/2009/02/02/mod-proxy-ajp-versus-mod-jk-round-1/

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.