Im using a PERC 3/DC controller to run a RAID 5 array using 4 hard disks. I am hoping to change this to 3 disks in the array and 1 hot spare. Is it possible to remove 1 disk from the array, reconfigure it as a hot spare, then reconfigure the RAID 5 array to use 3 disks WITHOUT loosing any data? I have backups but I would rather just reconfigure it without going through the hassle of restoring data. Thanks!


No, and if you have 4 disks and want two spares you are better off performance wise with a 4 disk RAID 10 instead of a 3 disk RAID 5 + hot spare. Either way your array will have 2 disks worth of usable capacity but the RAID 10 will have better write speeds and takes less time to recover from a failed disk.

Assuming the RAID 5 doesn't contain your boot volume, I'd go ahead and backup the data, reconfigure to a RAID 10, and restore the data.

    RAID Level Comparison for arrays up to 8 drives.
Features                RAID 0  RAID 1   RAID 5   RAID 6   RAID 10
Min Drives                2       2        3        4        4
Data Protection           0       1        1        2        2 (Up to one disk failure in each sub-array)
Read Performance         High    High     High     High     High
Write Performance        High   Medium    Low      Low     Medium
Degraded Read Perf       N/A    Medium    Low      Low      High
Degraded Write Perf      N/A     High     Low      Low      High
Capacity Utilization %   100     50      67-87    50-75     50
  • 2
    +1 Agree. Many people don't event think about raid 10, but in some situations is the best way to go. – PiL Jun 4 '10 at 13:25
  • Thanks for confirming my suspicions, and thanks for the RAID 10 idea, it hadnt even crossed my mind. Il get on it first thing Monday. – scampbell Jun 4 '10 at 14:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.