4
votes

Any recommendations for some forum software that fully supports listserv-style email discussion list functionality? Specifically, a forum that users can access online in the typical fashion or choose to interact with it strictly through email (both sending and receiving messages) like a traditional email discussion list (like mailman or majordomo). Let me emphasize that a forum with simple outbound notification is not sufficient -- I need email responses from users to post back to the forum.

I'd accept a reasonably priced hosted solution as well if it has good support. Yahoo and Google groups feature email access, but I need more support than either of those free hosting providers offer (if something breaks I need to be able email or actually talk to someone to get it fixed).

+2 points for actively maintained open source software
+1 point for user account integration with some CMS
+1 point for NNTP support at the same time (probably a pipe dream :)
+X points for nice feature set (email bounce handling, moderation, good SEO, etc.)
+1 point for Windows hosting compatibility

So far the only option I've really found is the enterprise edition of ActiveForums for DotNetNuke. Surely there must be other packages like this out there though. Any suggestions?

3
votes

GroupServer is pretty nice, GPLed, and has a hosted option.

You also have the option of running an nntp server and putting a web gateway in front of it. I've seen newsportal used, though FUDforum appears to be a more full-featured option.

2
  • Thanks! GroupServer and FUDForum both look like possible options. Now I need to do some research and experimentation. GroupServer looks good but I'm nervous about the slowness of development (2 years from 1.0 alpha to 1.0 beta) and their own forums aren't very active. They have a free hosted option which is great, but the private hosted options are pretty expensive. FUDForum also looks good and has a lot of features. It has mailing list and NNTP interfaces but they aren't integrated into the product. Have you used either of these yourself? – Scott Bussinger Jun 27 '10 at 18:47
  • Nope, at first I was just trying to remember the name of newsportal; they certainly are improvements. – Tobu Jun 27 '10 at 21:19
0
votes

phpBB2 was perfect for integrating a mailing list with a forum as there was a Mail2Forum MOD that provided the integration. This unfortunately is now just a discontinued phpBB2 MOD and an abondoned phpBB3 MOD. It is an excellent MOD though and I've been running a forum using it that's integrated with listserv for nearly 5 years.

There is one new MOD for phpBB3 - the forum-mailing list bridge that was created purely because he didn't want to wait for Mail2Forum to to make any progress. That is in the late alpha stage and is still active as of July last year, but I haven't tested it. When I get annoyed enough I'll eventually get around to direct porting the Mail2Forum MOD from phpBB2 to phpBB3.

Even though phpBB2 has been officially discontinued its an excellent forum and still has a community supporting it: http://www.phpbb2refugees.com/index.php

-1
votes

you can try phpbb

2
  • "listserv" is more than just "send email to a group of users". – Ignacio Vazquez-Abrams Jun 26 '10 at 7:46
  • As Ignacio suggests, I'm looking for real email discussion support not just notifications (meaning for instance that you can add a message to a forum by replying to an email). If PHPBB supports this, it's certainly not obvious from their website. – Scott Bussinger Jun 26 '10 at 17:22

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.