3

Most blade server systems can have an ethernet switch module or an ethernet pass-through module. What is the difference between both? Is the pass-though module simply "dumb" as a hub? Why would you choose one over the other?

4

A switch is a switch... just like any Ethernet switch.

A pass-through is just that, it's not a hub or anything. Just like a wall jack, wire on one side is passed through to the port on the other side.

If you want switching self contained to the blade enclosure (which is fairly normal, though not always) then get a switch. If have switches or want to use external switches for some reason you'll need a pass-through module so you can plug the blades into the external switch. Blades have no external connections (normally, with a very few exceptions).

  • 1
    Ok, but the strange thing is that our blade system with 5 blades has a pass-through module with 10 ports. But whatever port I choose, I can get a connection to every blade. So this seems to me more like a switch/hub then, or? – Zardoz Oct 3 '12 at 16:05
  • 2
    if you have a question about the behavior of a specific product, then you need to tell us what that product is. – longneck Oct 3 '12 at 16:07
  • It is a Supermicro blade enclosure. But I guess those pass-through modules work like every pass-through module else out there. – Zardoz Oct 3 '12 at 16:09
  • 1
    SuperMicro doesn't list any Pass-Through modules with 10 ports.. I think you're looking at a switch (The GEM-001 specifically). – Chris S Oct 3 '12 at 16:32
  • sounds like passthough just exposes each blades ethernet ports to the outside but is not a switch. If there are 2 ports per blade then 10 ports on the passthrough makes sense. You'd have to then provide a switch to allow the blades to talk with each other. – Matt Nov 9 '12 at 0:36
1

I only know IBM Bladecenters, so let's stick with this.

An IBM CoppeR Pass Thru Module is nothing but a transceiver which takes the Ethernet port from the Bladecenter's midplane and lets you connect regular RJ45 CAT-V cables to another switch. There is nothing you can configure and it's simply dumb. There are also Fibreoptics pass thru modules, in case you prefer those.

A real bladeswitch (like a Cisco 3110G) connects the blade's internal ethernet ports to internal ports in that switch module. To connect the blades to the outside world, you can use the four external Gigabit Ethernet copper ports.

Another switch would be the 3110X, which gives you a single 10 Gigabit Ethernet fibreoptics uplinks.

All those switches (at least the Cisco variants) can be stackec together to behave like a single switch with one configuration.

I havent tried the other switch brands for IBM, like Juniper and Brocade.

0

My experience with Dell Blade (PowerEdge M1000e) is almost the same as of the one from Alex with IBM Blade. You have up to 6 free slots for different modules such as switches on the back of the Dell PowerEdge M1000e. Normally they configure the first slot with Pass-through module with master role and the other 5 slots can be managed switches with 10Gb or 1Gb ports. If you connect the external switches to the pass-through you will have network connectivity between chassis components such as blade servers and the external switches with the same configs of the external switches. But if you'd like to have your own layer 2 configs on your blade or if you'd like to have 10G links, you may need to decide for managed Switch modules for your blade over only pass-through modules.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.