4

Like many people I am considering creating 'private cloud' using either OpenStack or VMware.

VMware vMotion has a nice feature which allows Live Migration of VMs even without shared storage. I have tried this feature in a lab environment and it works well. This feature is not without it's downsides but it is appealing for sites which need a simple VM environment and don't want to spring for the complexity and expense of shared storage. Shared storage can easily add $50-100K to the cost of a Virtual/Cloud infrastructure. More information on this feature at:

Does OpenStack using KVM offer a similar feature? Can OpenStack do live migration without shared storage? KVM is the default hypervisor for OpenStack and we'd prefer to stick with the default unless there is a compelling reason to use something else.

6

Openstack supports live migration without shared storage (with reservation):

Theoretically live migration can be done with non-shared storage, using a feature known as KVM live block migration. However, this is a little-known feature in OpenStack, with limited testing when compared to live migration, and is slated for deprecation in KVM upstream.

This doc is incomplete, however. One implementation of live migration was deprecated but a new (and better) implementation was done.

There was some discussion about this on the Openstack mailing list Apr 2013 where Daniel Berrange says:

What I wrote above about the existing impl is still accurate. The new block migration code is now merged into libvirt and makes use of an NBD server built-in to the QMEU process todo block migration. API wise it should actually work in the same way as the existing deprecated block migration code. So if you have new enough libvirt and new enough KVM, it probably ought to 'just work' with openstack without needing any code changes in nova. I have not actually tested this myself though.

  • live_migration.html certainly looks out-of-date based on the conversation from Daniel Berrange. I wonder if a newer version of that page is in the works. – Stefan Lasiewski Sep 16 '13 at 19:31
  • Can someone tell me what versions of libvirt and KVM are "new enough"? Daniel Berrange says "So if you have new enough libvirt and new enough KVM, it probably ought to 'just work' with openstack without needing any code changes in nova." – Stefan Lasiewski Sep 16 '13 at 20:26
  • It would be great to have something close to an authoritative answer. Another user on the list provided some information, but asked for clarification. Sylvain Bauza says "Waiting Daniel's reply, but afaik, the new NBD server is available since qemu-1.4 and libvirt 1.0.2" – Stefan Lasiewski Sep 16 '13 at 20:54

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.