5

A company with 50 graphic designers are working on the same file server. They are using mainly Indesign. A typical project is a 60 pages indesign document with 1.5GB of linked files (something like 100 PSD, JPG, .ai). They continuously edit linked files. This causes a lot of stress to the server. All worksations have onboard SSD (700MB/s) that are used only for system and apps.

I wonder if there are any way to use the local drive as a cache for remote folder. Let's say we assign 200GB for caching files. Each time a file is accessed it would check on the server the last change date and retrive the file only if cached data is obsolete. If a file change on the server it notify workstations. It would be thinked as a dropbox or google drive but with local server.

If anyone knows solutions of this kind, please, point me to it.

If there are not, I really wonder why. It is a need I see in every companies of this kind.

Adobe recomends to copy file locally, work, then re-upload. This is really painfull and impossible when 3 graphists are working on different chapters of the same book that share a lot of assets.

(Note this issue is soved but I let it for constiency with comments :) Using SMB it uses huge amount of CPU on the server, I think Indesign is watching after changes on the linked files and constantly request for changes. If a linked file is updated indesign immediately show a sign next to it. (Solution : when using afp to connect remote folders CPU usage on server is normal, there definetly an issue with SMB implementation on OSX.)

Anyway, I'm still looking for a way to mount remote folders... having local cache.

  • Surprisingly, most of the answers to this question for linux are valid for windows as well. – Andrew Domaszek Nov 27 '14 at 0:26
  • What are the client OS' and what is the OS of the "file server"? – TheCleaner Nov 27 '14 at 2:52
  • They are running on macOS, but I'm interested in a solution compatible with the 3 majo OSes (Linux, Windows, MacOS). – bokan Nov 27 '14 at 8:46
  • Branchcache is the first thing that comes to mind when speaking about Windows. However it is not available for other OSes. – Peter Lindqvist Dec 1 '14 at 11:04
  • 1
    You say SMB uses huge cpu power... sounds like there is an issue there that could be tuned in. You should investigate if this is CPU or CPU io.wait (io.wait perhaps indicates something to be tuned on filesystem mount/tunefs level, pure cpu used by SMB should indicate tuning smb.conf settings) – Antony Gibbs Dec 1 '14 at 23:53
0

From what you're describing, you're really looking for a distributed revision control system. It keeps a central repo on a server, and clients can check in for updates.

You're using Adobe Indesign, and I wasn't really able to find out what kind of integration option are out there for various revision control systems, but that's just some research. Adobe offers something called Bridge, but from its description it seems to be more focused on media, so I'm not sure it'll do what you need.

There are lots of options out there. I've used Perforce and Git. Admittedly those were with a focus towards software development, but we did use them for managing art assets and design documents.

I'm a strong proponent of using a system like this and having the designers/engineers check and pull for updates when they want to get the latest. Sometimes there is a benefit or desire to use an older version of a document, and going to this kind of system moves you away from SMB/CIFS shares and towards a managed version control system.

  • Thank you for trying to answer. I don't want control version I don't want them to check in/out (because they wil never bother doing this). Also GIT, SVN and others are made for textfile, they are not meant to be used for 500MB PSD files. I want it to be a transparent remote folder... with local cache. – bokan Dec 1 '14 at 23:10
  • 1
    get a graphist to commit via git.... good luck ;) – Antony Gibbs Dec 1 '14 at 23:47
0

From a normal fileshare perpective it would be hard to setup.

-- With offline file but in public/group folder last writer will win the save.

  • Another solution for Windows/IOS/MAC or even adroid is you could use WorkFolder in a near futur (Microsoft told that they will release client for those platform, but we don't have a release date yet). That mean you need a 2012R2 as your fileserver. The workfolder sync when you click a file to work with it. The same problem arise if you set a WorkFolder in a public's folder, the last writer win.

So the big question is do you need public folder, and does your employees work in the same files during the day ? If yes, we fallback to the SVN/GIT's idea

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.