4

I'm struggling to configure white labeling between sendgrid and 1and1.com.

Sendgrid asks me to create a variety of subdomains on my domain registrar with specific CNAME values. I'm able to create most of them but I was stuck on:

s1._domainkey.<mydomain>

1and1.com is giving me an "invalid subdomain error. The subdomain could not be created. An error has occurred" Anyone else come across this and resolved it? Do I need to switch registrars?

I can create the subdomain without the underscore but then it doesn't validate against sendgrid.

4

Got this question answered by SendGrid's support team. Pasting their response here:

If I recall, 1 & 1 doesn't support the _ value in the CNAME record.

What you can do is create a TXT record instead.

Head over to your SendGrid account -> Select Settings -> Whitelabel.

Delete your old whitelabel and add a new one using the same subdomain and domain ' mail.'. This time, Turn off the automated security box so we use TXT records vs. CNAME records for your DKIM config.

Back on 1and1.com's configuration screen I was able to create the TXT records as spec'd by SendGrid.

| improve this answer | |
  • I have tried this solution and it looks that now for TXT they generate a subdomain like this: m1._domainkey.... so they are using underscore here too. Maybe they changed since your answer. – Daniel Dudas Feb 8 '17 at 18:24
1

1&1 does not allow underscores in their DNS Records, or at least in their CNAME DNS Records, despite underscores being allow in the RFC. I can't find documentation from them on it, but it's a problem I've heard of many times in the past; you might want to contact their support to confirm.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.