I'm struggling to get a basic VLAN working across my equipment an HP V1910 switch and a SonicWall 3600 router.

Here is what I have:

HP V1910

VLAN 1 - Mgmt 192.168.10.x

VLAN 20 - Wireless 191.168.20.x

The following VLAN interfaces are defined on the HPV1910



Port #4 is my trunk to the Sonicwall

Port #4 is setup as: VLAN 1 [untagged], VLAN 20 [tagged], PVID 1, Link Type Trunk

Port #23 is my testing port. I have a Windows 7 machine plugged into it with a static IP of

Port #23 is setup as: VLAN 20 [tagged], VLAN 20

What I want to happen is that the Win7 box on Port 23 gets VLAN 20 assigned via port #23's PVID, and that traffic then sent to the SonicWall via port #4's trunk.

Some pictures of the HP setups:

HP Port 23 Details

HP VLAN 20 Port Details

SonicWall 3600

My interfaces on the SonicWall are as follows:

X0 - Zone LAN

X1 - Zone WAN --our public ip--

X7:V20 - Zone WIFI-LAN

The WIFI-LAN zone is setup as a trusted interface. Because of this the SonicWall auto-added routing between the LAN and the WIFI-LAN zones.

What do I set as the gateway on the Windows 7 computer? The Win7 box cannot ping the vlan interface on the Sonicwall or any other machine on the .10 subnet.

Any thoughts on where I have this setup wrong, or what information I can provide to fix it?


Maybe there is a little bit confusion. I don't use HP switch but on cisco will work in this way:

port 23 vlan20 untagged (pc port for internet browsing)
port 4 vlan20 tagged and vlan1 untagged
port 22 vlan1 untagged

So if you want to be ready for browsing you need to use port 23, for management you'll need to plug into 22 port. Otherwise it will be important to know if your sonic-wall (but i think so) can use 2 different vlans networks configuring 802.1q on the same interface. Of course you need to jump on interface 22 for Sysadmin configuration (and setting the right ip) and on interface 23 for browsing internet (setting the right ip) I hope it helps!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.