How many bluetooth headsets can exist in a small space without there being interference or reliability issues?

We're about to switch our phone infrastructure to IP. New phones are on the way and we just realized 1) Headset support is expensive (Wired or Wireless), 2) The phones we HAVE TO get (for a completely different reason) supports bluetooth.

Seven or more people will have Bluetooth capability on their new phones (Nortel 1140E). Most are within 10 feet from each other ('next-to' cubicles in a semi-circle), and in the center we have an Aruba Access point (802.11a/b/g) serving clients within a 30-40' radius.

Has any of you had experience with this? Do you have good recommendation(s) for minimizing interference? Do you have an opinion on the best bluetooth headset to support this kind of setup?


Bluetooth vs Bluetooth

Bluetooth should handle this reasonably well. The bluetooth radio layer actually frequency hops over 79 different frequencies spread 1MHz apart. Even with many people using them near each other, they shouldn't notice any degradation, and anything they do notice will be similar to the occasional packet drop over cellphones that doesn't impede communication at all. They hop at close to the same rate, and back off when they sense interference, which means that multiple bluetooth devices near each other will seamlessly synchronize so they are on different frequencies all the time with few collisions.

Bluetooth vs WiFi

Read this HP document to learn the details regarding WiFi and Bluetooth coexistence. To summarize:

Bluetooth interference from WiFi

In short, a single Wifi channel will interfere with about 22 of bluetooth's 79 hopping channels. In voice communications the packets will simply be dropped, but the modulation schemes are different, so this should only occur where the access point has a very strong signal.

WiFi intereference from Bluetooth

The access point, in turn, will slow down communications as it sees the bluetooth interference. Due to robust TCP/IP protocols most of your users won't notice anything other than slower access, however some realtime traffic (VOIP, video, etc) may suffer slightly greater packet loss since they won't be retried if lost.

Bluetooth automatically adjusts radio power according to its needs, this means that if the user is very close (within a few feet) of their phone, then the bluetooth signal will be very low power, and therefore interfere with very little. If they walk across the office, then the radio pumps out more power and interferes with many other radios nearby.

Testing will show whether this is a problem in your situation.

Alternative solution: 802.11 A 5.8GHz access point

You might consider using 802.11 A for your wireless network, which won't interfere with the bluetooth at all, being in the 5.8GHz band. A/B/G/N all in one wifi cards are common and cheap now, so there's little extra cost in going this route.

In summary

Yes, you will experience measurable interference. However it may not noticeably impact your operation depending on many, many factors, such as the network utilization, bluetooth utilization, radio strength, cubicle material, building composition and materials, nearby microwaves, etc, etc, etc.

In many cases this situation would work out fine, especially if you have few low bandwidth users on the wireless network, and only a few people chatting on the bluetooth at once.

In some cases regardless of other parameters you will find the situation unbearable - such as with the latest 802.11 N radios, which bond multiple channels and therefore saturate the 2.4GHz spectrum if users are using all 450mbps (or 600mbps if those radios are out yet...) and you've got 30+ people on bluetooth inside a single conference room with the AP in the middle.



Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.