15

I have a Heroku app and I need to set up a domain for it. The common way to set it up is to use CNAME record to specify that this domain is an alias to <your-domain-name>.herokuapp.com. The thing is, I also want to add Google Webmasters and Yandex.Metrika integrations and the easiest way is to add two TXT record for the domain. I set it up like that:enter image description here I need to have 2 TXT records on http://www.cscombo.com, but apparently this won't work because of this: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/34613083/cname-and-txt-record-for-same-subdomain-not-working

My current setup isn't working properly, because adding http://www.cscombo.com to the Google Webmasters wouldn't work (because TXT record for the www subdomain doesn't exist), and adding http://cscombo.com (non-www version) will work (the TXT record for this subdomain exists), but this way Google Webmasters won't be able to read both sitemap.txt and robots.txt (because they both redirect to the www version of the site). The same story with Yandex.Metrika.

So, the question: is there any way to add CNAME and TXT records for the same subdomain?

2
  • The obvious answer is not to use a wildcard CNAME. – Tim Feb 23 '17 at 0:42
  • @tim can you explain a little what should I change? – serge1peshcoff Feb 23 '17 at 0:45
32

You can't. As RFC1034 says in s3.6.2,

If a CNAME RR is present at a node, no other data should be present

If you want a TXT record for (say) www.example.com, you can't have a CNAME for www.example.com, and will have to find another way to achieve what you want. This may mean monitoring example.herokuapp.com yourself, and when the IP address changes, updating your own A records for www.example.com.

2
  • I would challenge this. Doesn't the word "should" indicate a recommendation here rather than a hard law? In what scenario would there be any practical real world issue with a TXT record coinciding with a CNAME? I've personally added TXT records to hostnames containing CNAME's without any problems. – David Backeus Dec 11 '20 at 10:03
  • @DavidBackeus famously, one should be conservative in what one sends, and generous in what one accepts. You're right that it often doesn't cause problems to publish such records, but sometimes it does, and they can be unpredictable, and difficult to diagnose. Why set yourself up for Heisenbugs? – MadHatter Dec 11 '20 at 11:18
2

A workaround would be to use an ALIAS record if your registrar supports it. It is a type of records that provides CNAME-like behavior on apex domains. Read more: https://support.dnsimple.com/articles/alias-record/#whats-an-alias-record

For example, you could create an ALIAS record for @ which points to myapp.herokuapp.com. This would allow you to also have TXT records for @ on the same domain name.

1
  • ALIAS is not defined by any standard, this is created by some providers, and called differently either ALIAS or ANAME or APEXCNAME or whatever else. – Patrick Mevzek Nov 13 '20 at 18:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.