I’ve inherited a setup where Exchange 2010 is installed on Windows Server 2008 R2, I want to upgrade to Exchange 2016 and Windows Server 2016. I’ve read Microsoft does not support upgrading OS when Exchange is installed. A further issue is that this server is also our main domain controller.

I believe the best scenario is to create a new Windows Server 2016 machine, install Exchange 2016 and migrate mailboxes across.

After that I’d decommission the Exchange 2010 part of the Windows Server 2008 machine and add the new 2016 server to the existing domain controller.

Is this the best approach, has anyone done something similar and what potential issues do you see from this approach?


I would start ramping up an additional server (must be joined to your current domain BEFORE you install MS Exchange 2016 on it; keep noted that there is no option to perform an in-place upgrade of MS Exchange, so you need a 2nd server here to move to a higher Exchange server) which will will later one host MS Exchange 2016 and then you need to perform the following steps:

  • Make sure the Schema is up to date to install MS Exchange 2016 (see here for more infos) if there is no Exchange 2016 server installed you need to upgrade that one during or before you install MS Exchange 2016.
  • Install MS Exchange 2016 (you can use the latest CU here, the ISO for the CU included the whole installer, then you start with an up to date environment. At the moment this is CU 6. Keep noted that .net 4.7 is currently not supported on Exchange 2016 as written here, so you might keep an eye on the patch management from your new server as it might come in automatically depending on your setup)
  • Configure MS Exchange 2016 to handle the MS Exchange 2010 traffic (called a Coexistence Environment, see here for some older but still valid infos)
  • Move the mailboxes from Exchange 2010 to Exchange 2016 (via New-MoveRequest as explained here)
  • Remove Exchange 2010 from the environment
  • Optional: Once done you could rampup an additional Domain controller and move the AD roles there, then demote the old Domain controller (you might wish to setup an ESXI environment and host Exchange and the Domain Controller on one hardware if your budget force you to do that).

Here is a howto which covered that in some very detailed steps.

P.S: Please keep noted that running MS Exchange on a Domain controller is not really supported. You really should change that!

  • Just to also add - adding or removing the DC role from an Exchange server is also not supported and will break Exchange. Therefore if you are planning to make the server a domain controller (against all advice) it must be done BEFORE Exchange is installed. Similarly you need to remove Exchange from the DC, not DC functionality with Exchange installed. – Sembee Aug 17 '17 at 11:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.