1

We get an HP DL360 G8 with an Smart Array P822 controller. On that controller will come a HP StorageWorks D2700.

Does anybody know, that it is possible to run the Smart Array P822 in HBA mode?

I found only information about the P410i, who can run HBA.

If this is not supported, what you think about the LSI 9207-8e controller? Will this fit good in that setup?

The Hardware we get is used but all original from HP. The StorageWorks has 25 x 900 GB SAS 10K disks. Because the disks are not new I would like to use only 22 for raid6, and the rest for spare (I need to see if the disk count is optimal or not for zfs). It would be nice if I'm not stick to SAS in future.

As OS I would like to install debian stretch with zfs 0.71 as file system and software raid. I have see that hp has an page for debian to.

I would like to use hba mode because it is recommend, that zfs know at most as possible about the disk, and I'm independent from the raid controller.

For us zfs have many benefits, but I think it is not necessary her to discus about this.

In the HP DL360 G8 I would like to connect some sata drives for a second pool. For this I will test to use normal consumer hdds.

  • What exactly are you planning to do? – ewwhite Sep 20 '17 at 20:16
  • For zfs it is not recommend to use a hardware raid under. So I need a controller with hba/jbo mode, that can pass the drives to the server. With zfs I will make then a raid6. – jb_alvarado Sep 21 '17 at 5:35
1

This question isn't formatted well and is missing a lot of information, but I'll get to the core technological point.

It sounds like you want to use ZFS on an HP server with an external drive enclosure. You can use ZFS however you wish: on a single drive, a single LUN or logical drive atop hardware RAID, with individual disks connected to an HBA. It all works, and just depends on your technical requirements.

I can give you an answer that relates to the hardware you've mentioned in your post: An HP Smart Array P822 can be place in "HBA mode" and provide visibility to the individual drives connected to its SAS expander ports. Here's an example of that configuration.

However, that's not an ideal solution for ZFS because the P822 has internal expanders. Plus, you should be using multipath SAS connections to your D2700 enclosure, assuming you're using SAS disks (not SATA). Use the HP H221 HBA instead of a RAID controller. An example of what that should look like is here: https://github.com/ewwhite/zfs-ha/wiki

enter image description here

Details about your proposed setup like, Linux OS version/kernel, disk types and application would help, since it's possible to make major irreversible mistakes with bad ZFS design.

  • Thank you ewwhite! I have add some more information's. I'm new to this kind of hardware, but I hope I will get everything right. Your github link is very interesting, but a HA solution is a bit much for us. We get this hardware very cheap, otherwise this would not be our level. Runs this HP H221 HBA controller good with zfs? I read many time that people recommend LSI. But for me the HP one would be good to. Multipath SAS connection means just 2 cables to the D2700? – jb_alvarado Sep 21 '17 at 11:43
  • The HP H221 is an HP-branded LSI controller, so it's the best option for you. Multipath in this case means two SAS cables... ONLY if you're using SAS disks in the D2700. If you're using SATA disks, they will not multipath. – ewwhite Sep 21 '17 at 12:26
  • Can I ask you one question more? People say that some non HP HDDs causes different problems - is this depending to the controller, or the server itself? When it's the controller, maybe I better take another, non HP controller. – jb_alvarado Sep 21 '17 at 19:31
  • You can use any SAS disk in a D2700 without problems. The problem is with Gen8 disks, internal disks (inside the server) and consumer SATA drives. – ewwhite Sep 21 '17 at 20:30
  • That is interesting and good to know - thank you again! – jb_alvarado Sep 22 '17 at 11:27

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.